The Spot-fixing Case - Case Summary

Legal Case Summary

Facts

In August 2010, members of the Pakistan cricket team were implicated in a spot-fixing scandal during the fourth Test match versus England, held at Lord's cricket ground. The implicated figures were Salman Butt, Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir, alongside player agent, Mazhar Majeed.

The central allegation was the deliberate delivery of intentional no-balls during the match, a move that allowed underground bookies to make substantial profits.

The sting operation was primarily conducted by News of the World, who provided video evidence of Mazhar Majeed accepting money and confirming the exact delivery times of the deliberate no-balls.

Issues

The primary issue was to ascertain whether the accused had conspired to cheat at gambling and accept corrupt payments, charges under the Gambling Act 2005 and the Prevention of Corruption Act 1906.

Further issues revolved around determining the intentions of the accused and whether their actions adversely affected the integrity of the sport of cricket.

Analysis

The Spot-fixing Case was significant in how it unseated the image of cricket, considered a 'gentleman's game'. This case revealed the exploitation of the sport for gambling and corruption purposes.

Following this case, the ICC adopted stricter measures to curb such malpractice in cricket. It also underlined the importance of education for players regarding the ethical parameters of the game.

Decision

Ruling

In November 2011, the accused were found guilty, buttressing the earlier decision of the International Cricket Council (ICC) which had imposed a five-year ban on the players.

Salman Butt, Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir were respectively sentenced to 30 months, one year and six months imprisonment. Mazhar Majeed received a sentence of 2 years and 8 months.

References

• Spot-fixing controversy: A timeline of events. (2011). Sky Sports. Retrieved 20 October, 2021, from www.skysports.com
• Burnton, S. (2011). Pakistan cricketers' fixing trial: how it happened. The Guardian. Retrieved 20 October, 2021, from www.guardian.co.uk

---

Journalist Brief

In 2011, a major scandal hit cricket when a sting operation by News of the World implicated several members of the Pakistan cricket team in a spot-fixing scheme during a Test match against England. The accused were found guilty of conspiring to cheat at gambling and accepting corrupt payments. This pivotal case highlighted the possible extent of corruption in cricket, leading to stricter measures by the International Cricket Council.

FAQs

Who were the players involved in the Spot-fixing Case?

Answer: The players involved were Salman Butt, Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir.

What were the sentences given to the convicted persons?

Answer: Salman Butt was sentenced to 30 months, Mohammad Asif to one year, Mohammad Amir to six months and Mazhar Majeed to 2 years and 8 months.

What was the impact of this case on cricket?

Answer: This case led to stricter measures by the International Cricket Council to curb such malpractice in cricket and highlighted the necessity of player education on the ethical parameters of the game.